Question. On what part of the body was the lash laid on?
Answer. On the buttocks I think.
Question. Did you see any prisoners tied up?
Answer. Yes; lifted up on their toes.
Question. did you ever knock a prisoner down?
Answer. No, sir.
Question. Did you ever strike a prisoner?
Answer. Yes; after the prisoners struck me.
Question (by the CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE). What is Captain Alexander's treatment of the prisoners generally?
Answer. He is sometimes kind sometimes the reverse of kindness.
Question (by Mr. WARD). Do you know what provocation the captain had in thus speaking?
Answer. No; but I have heard him speak very snappish when prisoners were being put in. He expressed himself only in language.
Question. What was his language?
Answer. Well, something like, "Shove them in there" "Put them in there, God damn them. "
Question (by Mr. WARD). Did not the prisoners refuse to be put back sometimes and resist-so much so as to require the exercise of force?
Answer. I never had a prisoners to refuse to go in, but I have had them to resist me on the street.
J. F. SCHAFFER, detective, was recalled to the stand.
By the CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE:
Question. What is the deportment of Caphart toward prisoners?
Answer. I have known him to be very abusive, generally, when prisoners were impudent to him. I have heard him curse prisoners under arrest when they held back or resisted him.
Question. Did you ever see men tied up by the thumbs?
Answer. I have seen prisoners tied up either by the thumbs or the wrists. It is called "trusting up" and is a sailor's punishment.
Question (by the CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE). For what offenses were those you saw tied up?
Answer. For bribing the guard I believe. I don't know whether they were Yankees or Confederate volunteers.
Question. Do you remember on a certain occasion when eight or ten men were whipped?
Answer. I heard it rumored; didn't see it.
Question. Is Caphart's conduct toward prisoners abusive?
Answer. No; except on occasions; he was rather kind.
Question (by Mr. WARD). Mr. Schafter, don't you think Caphart as good an officer as there is on the force?
Answer. I must say I have heard him abuse the prisoners very much. I have heard him use some very harsh language toward them.