| Page 1 | (The Son Tay Raid: A Study in Presidential Policy) |  |  |
THE SON TAY RAID: A STUDY IN PRESIDENTIAL POLICY
'Freedom is the sure possession of those
alone who have the courage to defend it.'
-
Pericles
The raid force approached the hamlet of Son Tay
in North Vietnam at 0230 hours on 21 November 1970. Flying over the hills at
treetop level, the helicopters and their escorts could see the yellow lights of
Hanoi winking in the cool night air. Suddenly, they were over the camp at Son
Tay and the sky, which had been bathed in the pale light of a waning moon,
exploded in brilliant light as flares and muzzle flashes filled the night sky.
The escort aircraft fired on pre-selected targets and dropped fire-fight
simulators in several locations near the camp. Simultaneously, the lead
helicopter passed over the camp and destroyed two guard towers with a laser beam
like stream of bullets. Seconds later, another helicopter executed a planned
crash-landing into the middle of the camp as its blades chewed into a high tree.
The helicopter hit the ground with a thud and fourteen heavily armed raiders
burst from the crippled machine with chainsaws, axes, and bolt cutters in tow.
The fourteen liberators began fighting their way to the prisoners' cells. Amid
the confusion of combat a blaring bullhorn announced that Americans had landed
and were here to rescue POWs. The prison came alive, cracking with fire of
automatic weapons. A large explosion blew a hole in the prison wall as the
raiders from a third helicopter which landed
outside of the camp made their entrance. Meanwhile, another helicopter landed at
a location that looked very similar to the Son Tay POW camp. Within seconds of
touchdown, the disembarked raiders found themselves in a huge fire-fight
unfolding all around them. Four violent ground battles were now raging within
the Son Tay area: one at the prison, another at an undisclosed location, and two
faked by air delivered fire-fight simulators. However, before the helicopter
could get back to pick up the force deposited by mistake, the raiders had killed
approximately 150 enemy soldiers without any raider casualties, while the
location burned like a roman candle. Back at the prison camp, nearly 60 enemy
guards lay dead or wounded as the raiders swarmed over and through the camp like
robots. As the raiders broke into one cell after another, they were reporting
'negative items' (no prisoners). After the last cell was opened and the other
cells checked again, the mission commander was informed that the search was
complete with no items. The raiders were stunned to find that the prison was
totally empty of POWs. The raid force departure was as quick and ghost-like as
their arrival, leaving behind a wake of death and destruction as their calling
card. However, they left empty-handed. The Son Tay Raid was over. What had gone
wrong? Had the mission been compromised? Had the raiders fought their way out of
a poorly executed trap? Was the mission really designed to rescue POWs or was
there some other motive? What political intentions and ramifications did the
current Administration seek? Was the war in Vietnam about to take a dramatic
turn from the stated policy of Vietnamization? In an attempt to answer these
questions, this paper will examine the political/strategic goals and
intentions of the Administration's policies regarding
the war in Vietnam. More specifically, was the policy reflected in the actions
taken at Son Tay?
| Page 1 | (The Son Tay Raid: A Study in Presidential Policy) |  |  |
|